All guidesmovie reviews

    Ebenezer Review Roundup: Depp Divides Critics and Fans

    Johnny Depp's Ebenezer split critics (54%) and audiences (90%). A spoiler-free look at Ti West's Christmas Carol, its box office, and who it's for.

    AH

    Adrian Hayes

    Nov, 2026

    7 min read

    Last updated: November 16, 2026. Scores and box office were reported on November 15 and will move as more people see the film.

    Johnny Depp has the number one movie in America, and the critics would like a word. Ebenezer, Ti West's foggy, gothic take on A Christmas Carol, opened to $19 million domestically and a much louder argument online. On Rotten Tomatoes it sits at 54% with critics and 90% with audiences. That is not a small gap. That is two different films sharing a poster.

    One honest note before we start: this is a review roundup, not a screening review. I haven't seen Ebenezer yet, so I'm not going to invent a star rating or pretend I did. What I can do is sort the evidence — what critics like, what they don't, what audiences are rewarding, and whether the gap tells you anything useful.

    Quick answer: is Ebenezer worth watching?

    Short version: Ebenezer is a handsomely made, very faithful Christmas Carol with a committed Depp performance, a stacked supporting cast and almost no interest in reinventing Dickens. Critics found it redundant. Audiences, especially Depp fans, mostly had a good time. If you want a spooky, traditional Scrooge, it is worth a ticket. If you want Ti West at his most dangerous, temper expectations.

    The basics

    DetailInfo
    Release dateNovember 13, 2026 (US and UK)
    DirectorTi West
    WriterNathaniel Halpern, based on Charles Dickens
    GenreHoliday comedy horror
    CastJohnny Depp, Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Tramell Tillman, Ian McKellen, Sam Claflin, Daisy Ridley
    Runtime116 minutes
    RatingPG-13 (US), 12A (UK)
    StudioParamount Pictures
    Reported budget$38 million

    Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge in a dark Victorian doorway

    Johnny Depp in Ebenezer. Image: Paramount Pictures, via ScreenRant.

    What is Ebenezer about? (no spoilers)

    The setup is the one you know. On Christmas Eve in 1836, Ebenezer Scrooge loses his business partner, Jacob Marley. Seven years later he is a bitter man who refuses his nephew's dinner invitation and turns away two men collecting for the poor. Then Marley's ghost arrives with a warning and a schedule: three spirits are coming.

    The film follows the familiar Past, Present and Yet to Come structure. The selling point is tone. West shoots Dickens' London like a haunted house — fog, candlelight, ghosts that actually feel like ghosts — and Depp plays Scrooge as a man who has decided that being unpleasant is a personality. It is PG-13, so this is atmosphere and creeping dread rather than a gore fest.

    The supporting cast is genuinely stacked: Rupert Grint as Bob Cratchit, Andrea Riseborough as the Ghost of Christmas Past, Tramell Tillman as the Ghost of Christmas Present, Ian McKellen as Marley, plus Sam Claflin, Daisy Ridley and Charlie Murphy. Several critics have pointed out that the film does not give them enough to do, which is a polite way of saying the movie knows exactly whose name is on the poster.

    What critics are praising

    The craft is the consensus bright spot. Rotten Tomatoes' critics consensus credits the film's "evocative production design," and Variety's review headline calls it "spookily atmospheric" before getting to the part about it being redundant. Checco Varese's cinematography and Tyler Bates' score are doing a lot of the heavy lifting.

    Depp is the other dividing line. The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw gave it three stars and wrote that it is a "perfectly serviceable, faithful adaptation" and that "as Scrooge himself, Depp is pretty good." Ian McKellen, who plays Marley, told People that Depp is "in spankingly good form." That is a better blurb than most of the official marketing.

    And the ghost sequences work for a lot of reviewers. The film pushes Dickens' innate eeriness harder than most adaptations, which is the one place where West's horror instincts clearly show up.

    What critics are grumbling about

    The main complaint is that it is another Christmas Carol that does not need to exist. The New York Times' Brandon Wu called it bland and wrote that "at his worst, Depp appears as if he is in a Scrooge costume in a Christmas-season ad campaign for Verizon. At his best, he is competent." IndieWire's David Ehrlich was harsher, calling Depp "insufferable." Dread Central asked, "who even asked for this?" and said the film is "content to lazily copy and paste." ScreenDaily concluded that it "ends up languishing somewhere in the mediocre middle."

    ScreenRant's own review, by Liz Declan, gave it five out of 10 and argued that it "falls flat" because it has nothing interesting to say and wastes its supporting cast. That is the recurring note: strong pieces, familiar assembly.

    The politics of Scrooge

    The most interesting criticism is not about whether Depp is good. It is about what the film does with Dickens' politics. The San Francisco Chronicle's Mick LaSalle and Den of Geek's David Crow both took issue with the adaptation's reversal of Dickens' social justice themes, particularly the choice to make the men collecting for the poor into con artists and to give Scrooge's disdain for the poor a narrative justification.

    You do not need to agree with that reading to see why it landed badly with some critics. A Christmas Carol is a story about a rich man learning that poor people are not the problem. A version that flips the charity collectors into frauds is making a different argument, whether it means to or not. That is a legitimate debate to have about the film. It is also the kind of choice that makes a "safe" adaptation feel less safe than it looks.

    The 54 versus 90 problem

    PlatformScoreWhat it measures
    Rotten Tomatoes critics54%123 reviews
    Rotten Tomatoes audience90%500+ verified ratings
    Metacritic46/10037 critics
    CinemaScoreA-Opening-night audience
    PostTrak4.5/563% definitely recommend

    Scores as of November 15, 2026. Sources: Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, ScreenRant, CinemaScore and PostTrak via Wikipedia.

    These numbers are not measuring the same thing, which is why the gap looks bigger than it feels. Rotten Tomatoes critics is the share of reviews that are positive, not an average score. Metacritic is a weighted average and is much less forgiving of a mixed three-star review. The audience score is self-selected people who bought a ticket, and CinemaScore is the opening-night crowd, which is the most generous possible sample.

    A 90% audience score two days in is a first wave, not a verdict. It can drift. But the direction is clear: the people who wanted a Depp Scrooge got one, and they are enjoying it. The people who review films for a living wanted a reason for another Christmas Carol to exist, and most of them did not find one.

    The audience reviews on Rotten Tomatoes, as quoted by ScreenRant, are doing a lot of the emotional work: "one of the best versions of Scrooge/Ebenezer I have seen," "dark comedy at its best," "Welcome back Johnny Depp." One dissenter called him "a little miscast." That is not a consensus. It is a vibe, and it is the vibe that sold the tickets.

    Box office: a modest win with a long game

    Ebenezer opened at number one with $19 million from 3,535 theaters, including $6.7 million on its first day and $1.5 million in Thursday previews. It added $23 million internationally for a $42 million worldwide start. It is Depp's first number one opening in eight years, according to the Associated Press.

    The budget was a reported $38 million, with a reported $50 million marketing spend. That is a lot of tinsel to earn back, and a $19 million opening is fine rather than triumphant. The holiday corridor is the saving grace: adult Christmas films can hold through Thanksgiving and December if audiences keep recommending them. The audience score suggests they might. The critic score suggests the ceiling is lower than the opening suggests.

    Is Ebenezer worth watching?

    Watch it if you are a Depp fan, you like gothic Dickens, you want a Christmas ghost story that is spooky without being nasty, or you are building a holiday movie night around a familiar story.

    Skip it or wait if you want Ti West's usual danger, you are tired of faithful Christmas Carol adaptations, or the film's approach to Dickens' politics would bother you more than the atmosphere would entertain you.

    Worth the ticket? For Depp fans, yes. For the curious, a matinee. For everyone else, wait for streaming. No streaming date has been announced in the sources we checked.

    If you want another 2026 case of critics and audiences telling different stories, our Godzilla Minus Zero review roundup is a good chaser. And if you are choosing between this and the rest of the December slate, our Dunesday breakdown has the calendar.

    FAQ

    Is Ebenezer scary?

    It is PG-13 in the US and 12A in the UK, so expect gothic atmosphere, ghost imagery and a few jumps rather than gore. It is a haunted-house Christmas Carol, not a slasher.

    Is Ebenezer faithful to A Christmas Carol?

    Mostly, yes. It follows the novella's structure closely. It does change the ending and reworks the charity subplot, which is where a lot of the critical debate is coming from. If you want a completely traditional version, this is close but not exact.

    Is Johnny Depp good in Ebenezer?

    Critics are split. The Guardian called him "pretty good," the New York Times called him "competent" at best, and IndieWire called the performance "insufferable." Audiences are much warmer, with Depp the most-praised part of the film in Rotten Tomatoes audience reviews.

    Where can I watch Ebenezer?

    It is in theaters now. No streaming date has been announced.

    Will there be a sequel?

    There is no announced sequel. The film is a complete adaptation of the novella, and Paramount has not said anything about continuing it.

    Sources

    Watching it with someone far away?

    If your movie night is split across two cities, WatchWithMe keeps the film in sync and the video chat in one place. Add it to Chrome, open the movie, and press play once.